The Toll

Tracking Chattanooga's Homicides


Garner Isbill

Date: 04/18/12

Gender: Male

Age: 76

Race: White

Time: Undetermined

Suspect(s): John Moncier, 28; Jennifer Hatfield-Streeval, 32

Status: Suspects convicted

What happened:

Garner Isbill, 76, is severely beaten at a hotel at 7300 Lee Highway. Isbill is initially hospitalized in critical condition after the beating and dies May 23. Jennifer Hatfield-Streeval, 32, and John Monicer, 28, are charged with criminal homicide. They tell police they believed Isbilll had molested their daughter. Moncier pleads guilty to voluntary manslaughter in 2014 and is sentenced to nine years. Hatfield-Streeval pleads guilty to aggravated assault and is sentenced to five years.

Read more:

Elderly man beaten by Chattanooga woman dies; charges boosted
Molestation claim questioned in beating death

Where it happened: